Main site of science textbooks
Crowdfunding site for the free
online science textbooks project

Leagues and Playoff Systems
Dr. Jay Maron

College conference realignment
Quarterback rankings
Steroids and the Baseball Hall of Fame
Where to put a new pro team?
Scoring systems
Prize money

International Rugby
Glorify the regular season
New Sport
College Hockey
College Rugby
UK Premier League


Game of Conferences

Colleges wage feudal war over TV markets, and the Big Ten and SEC won. For football, they're far stronger than other conferences.

Stadiums

The Big Ten and SEC have supremacy for stadiums and TV ratings. Outside the Big 10 and SEC, the biggest stadiums are Clemson, Florida State, and Notre Dame, and the biggest TV ratings are Notre Dame and Florida State.

Recruiting

The Big Ten and SEC dominate recruiting. The plot shows recruiting ranks averaged over the past 4 years, along with the AP rank averaged over the past 18 years.

For 2022, the SEC has 9 of the top 16 recruiting classes, and 15 SEC teams are in the top 32.

Among the top 64 recruiting teams, all are in the Power 4.

Rose Bowl

The new Big 10 owns almost all the Rose Bowl wins and the new Pac 12 has none. The table shows Rose Bowl wins from the classical era from 1947 to 2014, when the champions of the Big 10 and Pac 12 played. It excludes 2002 and 2006, when the Rose Bowl was the national championship game.

Rose Bowl wins:

Big 10 originals         35
Pac 12 originals         37
USC + UCLA + Wash + Ore  32
Stanford                  4
Arizona State             1
Big 10 now               67
Pac 12 now                0

UCLA, USC, Washington, and Oregon could play a round robin each year and call it the Pac 12 championship.

The Michigan Big House is the new Rose Bowl.

Poach history

Food chains:

Big 10 ← Pac 12 ← Mountain West ← CUSA ← Sun Belt ← FCS
SEC ← Big 12 ← AAC ← CUSA ← Sun Belt ← FCS
AAC ← Big East

U. Chicago has 7 Big Ten titles. They withdrew from the Big Ten in 1946 and canceled the football team. Football was a distraction to academics.

Pacific Conference

The Pacific Conference lost schools to the Big 10, these being UCLA, USC, Washington, and Oregon. To the Big 12 they lost Colorado, Utah, Arizona, and Arizona St. To the ACC they lost Cal and Stanford. The only remaining schools were Washington St and Oregon St. Then the Pacific Conference poached from the Mountain West, namely Boise St, Colorado St, San Diego St, and Fresno St.

If the Pacific Conference poaches again, contenders include:

                         Metro    Students    Stadium     State      TV
                       thousands  thousands  thousands  thousands  mil/game

AAC            San Antonio  2602      35        64      30503        .288     Alamodome
AAC            Tulane       1271      14        81       4574        .480     Superdome
AAC            Memphis      1338      22        58       7126        .336
Mountain West  UNLV         2265      31        65       3194        .287
Mountain West  San Jose St                      22                   .312

Las Vegas announced that it's staying in the Mountain West.

The status of 5th-most powerful conference is a tie between the Pacific Conference and the AAC. It's wise to poach from the AAC. San Antonio is AAC and it's a big market, a big school, and a big stadium. Triple big. Texas big. It's also a big market with no NFL team, and one of the likeliest places for a new NFL team.

The Pacific conference could also raid Tulane and Memphis from the AAC.

Tourist destinations should be favored, such as Las Vegas, Hawaii, and Tulane. These places are good for November games.

The Mountain West responded by adding El Paso and by giving bonuses to Las Vegas and Air Force. Air Force was being courted by the AAC, where it could join Army and Navy.

The Mountain West will likely add more schools. Contenders include Sacramento St, Texas St, Northern Illinois, and New Mexico St.

It's possible that the Mountain West could recruit from the FCS, and teams under consideration include Idaho, Montana, Montana St, North Dakota St, and South Dakota St.

The fee to move from FCS to FBS was once 5 k$ and is now 5 M$.

Notre Dame

Notre Dame plays 6 ACC teams per year. Once could imagine Notre Dame switching to Big 10 teams for bigger TV revenue. Playing Big 10 teams also helps if you're a national championship contender, and it gives the Big 10 an edge over the SEC. Notre Dame is at the geographic center of the Big 10 with 6 teams within a 3-hour drive. Notre Dame's schedule in games/year is:

Conference   Average   2024  2025  2026  2027 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37

ACC             6        5     5     5     5  5  5  5  6  5  5  5  5  5  5  Always Stanford
Big 10          2.5      2     2     4     1  1     1  1     1  1           Always USC
AAC             1.5      2     1     1     1  1  2  1  2  1                 Always Navy
SEC              .5      1     2              1  1  1  1  1
MAC             1        2
Big 12           .5
Mtn West         .5
Pacific         0              1
Sun Belt        0
South           0
Total                   12    11    10     7  8  8  8 10  7  6  6  5  5  5

"Games/year" is averaged over 2016-2024. We regard USC as always having been in the Big 10, and Stanford and Cal as always having been in the ACC.

Notre Dame's future schedule has space. They play Stanford through 2024, USC through 2026, and Navy through 2032. Presumably the USC and Navy games will be renewed, and Stanford is less certain. Big games include USC, Texas AM, and Stanford in 2024. USC and Texas AM in 2025. USC in 2026. Michigan St in 2027. Alabama in 2030. Michigan in 2033 and 2034.

Notre Dame is often involved in big non-conference games. Decades ago, there were never enough big non-conference games to properly decide bowls, and Notre Dame was a big help. Today, the Big 10 and SEC dominate, so the bowl picture will be more clear.

The Big 10 teams that Notre Dame plays frequently are USC, Purdue, Michigan State, and Michigan. Notre Dame could potentially join the Big 10. The schedule would be 9 Big 10 teams, Stanford, Navy, and one free game.

Among ACC teams, Notre Dame always plays Stanford, and the other teams are random. Notre Dame has long-standing rivalries with Pittsburgh and Georgia Tech, but these teams don't get special favoratism today. Notre Dame also has long-standing rivalries with Army and Air Force but rarely plays these teams today.

Notre Dame's rivalries are:

                 Games   W   L   T

Navy         AAC   95   81  13   1
USC          B10   91   49  37   5
Purdue       B10   85   57  26   2
Michigan St  B10   77   47  29   1
Pittsburgh   ACC   72   50  21   1
Army         AAC   51   39   8   4
Michigan     B10   43   17  25   1
Georgia T    ACC   37   30   6   1
Stanford     ACC   36   22  14
Air Force    MW    30   24   6
Miami        ACC   26   17   8   1
N Carolina   ACC   23   21   2
Boston C     ACC   20   17   3
Penn St      B10   19    9   9   1
Nebraska     B10   16    7   8   1
Florida St   ACC   11    5   6
Clemson      ACC    8    3   5
Promotion and relegation

Conference realignment saw 5 teams relegated from power conferences and 6 teams promoted to power conferences. The promoted teams are all in the Big 12 and these are TCU, BYU, Utah, Cincinnati, Houston, and UCF. The relegated teams were from the Big East and are Connecticut, Temple, and South Florida.

In 2004, there were 6 power football conferences, one of which was the Big East. The Big East had 12 schools, 9 of which defected to other power conferences. The 3 that didn't were relegated and are now minnows. We went from the Power6 to the Power5.

The Pac 12 once had 12 teams. 10 left for other power conferences, leaving 2 behind. Relegation. We're now down to the Power 4.

Texas Christian University achieved upward mobility by winning the Rose Bowl in the 2010 season, and in 2012 they moved from the Mountain West to the Big 12. They made the national championship bracket in 2022.

The Big Ten and SEC deserve their own tier. We could call them "superpowers". The non-superpowers need to adjust. Some might declare independence. We might see an alliance of independents, and independents might form their own version of a conference championship. They could keep an open week on the schedule for spontaneous games.

The Big Ten and the SEC don't need the NCAA. They could secede from the NCAA and go pro. Other conferences will be forced to follow.

TV markets

         Teams   States   Stadium     TV viewers    TV revenue   Conf revenue  Exit fee  TV contract
                         thou/team   Mil/team/game  M$/yr/team    M$/yr/team   M$/team    end year

Notre Dame   1     1        81         3.46         67             22.1        120         2029
Big 10      18    12        72         2.02         21             60.5          0         2030
SEC         16    12        83         2.14         21             51           30         2034
ACC         17     9        57         1.01         12.5           43.3        120         2036
Big 12      16    10        55         1.27         12.5           46           50         2031
Pac 12       7     6        37          .68                        34            0
AAC         14              50          .33                         9           17
MW           8              44          .16                                      6
MAC         12              32          .072
CUSA         9              32          .099         3                           1.75
Sun Belt    14              13          .085                                     5
Big East     0                                                                   7.5

The playoffs generate $470 million and total TV revenue is $2250 million. The Pac 12 doesn't yet have a long-term TV contract.

The ACC exit fee applies to teams that want to leave before 2036.

The revenue totaled over all sports and over all Power 5 schools, for 2022, is:

       Million $    %

TV        4227     42
Donors    2206     22
Tickets   1647     16.5
Other     1257     12.6
Bowls      621      6.2
Bowls

The bowl system needs reform. There will be teams from the Big Ten and SEC that have losing records but are worthy of bowls. The problem can be solved by letting everyone play bowls.

Traditionally, bowl games are between teams that are equally-matched in strength. College football will adopt a 12-team bracket in 2026, and the first two rounds will typically be mismatches. The college football postseason will look like the college basketball postseason.

In the 12-team bracket, many teams will play multiple postseason games. Teams outside the bracket might demand to do so as well.

To decide bowl matchups, there is rarely enough information from interconfence games to properly compare conferences, suggesting that we need more than 1 round of bowls. Notre Dame is often a vital benchmark for interconference strength. It would be nice to have more independents.

The future may see future expansion of the playoffs. There will be fights between conferences over playoff spots.

Number of playoff teams     Years

         0                    <1998
         2                1998-2013     BCS era
         4                2014-2023     Playoff era
        12                2024-

Plebe realignment

The plebe conferences, from strongest to weakest, are Pac12, AAC, MW, CUSA, MAC, Sun They're geographiclly uncompact and they could be reorganized to be more compact. There are 64 teams and the number of conference could be expanded to 8 to shrink the conferences to 8 teams/conferences. For example,

Washington St Wash          Hawaii       Hawaii     New Mex     New Mex
Oregon St     Oregon        Fresno St    Cal        New Mex St  New Mex
Boise St      Idaho         San Diego St Cal        Texas St    Texas
Utah St       Utah          San Jose St  Cal        Sam Houston Texas
Colorado St   Col           Nevada       Nevada     North Texas Texas
Air Force     Col           UNLV         Nevada     Rice        Texas
Wyoming       Wyoming                               UTEP        Texas
                                                    UTSA        Texas
                                                    Tulsa       Oklahoma
Missouri St   Missouri      Madison         Miss
W Kentucky    Kentucky      S Miss          Miss
Memphis       Tennessee     Jacksonville St Alabama
M Tennessee   Tennessee     Troy Alabama    Alabama
Ark St        Arkansas      S Alabama       Alabama
Lousiana T    Louisiana     UAB             Alabama
Louisiana Mon Louisiana     Kennesaw St     Georgia
Louisiana Laf Louisiana     Georgia St      Georgia
Tulane        Louisiana     Georgia S       Georgia

Army          New York      Lib N           North Carolina
Delaware      Delaware      UNC Charlotte   North Carolina
Temple        Penn          E Carolina      North Carolina
App St        W Virginia    Coast Carolina  South Carolina
Marshall      W Virginia    FIU             Florida
Old Dominion  Virginia      S Florida       Florida
Navy          Virginia      Florida At      Florida

The Mid-American conference is unchanged because it's already compact.

FCS realignment

Some FCS conferences are highly uncompact, such as the Pioneer conference. The appendix has a geographic realigment of the FCS. Pioneer Conference:

San Diego         California
Saint Thomas      Minnesota
Drake             Iowa
Butler            Iowa
Valpariso         Indiana
Dayton            Ohio
Morehead St       Kentucky
Marist            New York
Davidson          N Carolina
Presbyterian      S Carolina
Stetson           Florida
Texas

Texas has the most FBS teams and New York is weak.

State   Oligarchs   Plebes

Texas       6         6
California  4         3
Florida     3         3
N Carolina  3         3
Indiana     3         1
Alabama     2         4
Georgia     2         3
Michigan    2         3
Miss        2         2
Illinois    2         1
Tennessee   2         2
Virginia    2         2
Utah        2         1
Penn        2         1
Ohio        1         7
Louisiana   1         4
W Virginia  1         2
New York    1         2

College season

In the 2020 covid season, during conference championship week, the Big Ten had all teams play a game. The idea wasn't continued the next season.

In the 2020 season, the game between Liberty and Coastal Carolina was canceled, and Liberty scheduled a game with BYU on 3 day's notice.

The Big Ten has 18 teams and the SEC has 16, forcing them to adjust their scheduling systems. Divisions will be scrapped, and the new systems will favor local games and traditional rivalries.

Conference championship week could be more flexible. Sometimes it's strategic to have a conference championship game and sometimes not. Sometimes the conference championship is already decided before the championship game, in which case it's strategic for the top teams to play teams from other conferences. A pre-bowl game.

The Pac 12 is now the Pac 2. Washington State and Oregon State need to make a move. An option is to go independent and dare more teams to follow. Another option is to invite the best of the Mountain West, and this would consist of San Jose State, San Diego State, UNLV, Utah State, Colorado State, Boise State, and Hawaii. Another option is to join the Mountain West.


Glorify the regular season

In college football, the regular season matters. The postseason consists of only one bowl game.

Home field advantage matters more for the NFL than for the NBA, hence the NFL regular season is more important than the NBA regular season.

For any given sport, the fewer teams in the playoffs, the more important the regular season. MLB has only 12 postseason teams.

The English Premier League has no postseason. The winner is decided purely by the regular season.

     Playoff   Total
      teams    teams

MLB     12     30
NFL     14     32
NHL     16     32
NBA     16     30
NFL playoffs

In the NFL, each regular season win tends to increase the playoff seed by 1.

The following table gives the average number of regular season wins for each seed, using data from 2007-2016. The regular season has 16 games.

Seed   Wins   Privilege

  1    13.3   Home field for the quarterfinal and semifinal.  Wildcard bye
  2    12.1   Home field for the quarterfinal.                Wildcard bye
  3    10.9   Home field for the wildcard game.
  4     9.2   Home field for the wildcard game.
  5    11.0
  6    10.0
Seeds 1-4 go to division winners and seeds 5-6 go to the best records among the remaining teams.

The frozen tundra of Lambeau Field, Green Bay, Wisconsin

Home field advanage can be especially important for cold-weather teams like the Packers.

NBA playoffs

In the NBA, the regular season has little impact on the playoffs. For example, suppose the Milwaukee Bucks are the best team and they win the conference and gain the #1 seed. In the conference playoffs they can expect to face the 8th, 4th, and 2nd seeds. If the Bucks decide to slack and place 8th, they can expect to face the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd seeds in the playoffs. But since the Bucks are the best team, the 1st seed is the 2nd best team, the 2nd seed is the 3rd best team, etc.

                                                      Rank of teams played in playoffs

If the Bucks play hard and place 1st in the conference:   2nd, 4th, and 8th
If the Bucks slack and place 8th in the conference:       2nd, 4rd, and 3rd
No matter what, the Bucks will face the 2nd and 4th ranked team. The only difference between playing hard and slacking is that they have to play the 3rd ranked team instead of the 8th ranked team.

The following table gives the average number of games won by each seed, using data from 2009-2016. The regular season has 82 games. The difference between the 1st and 8th seeds is typically 20 games. That's a lot of slack.

Seed   Wins

  1    60.8
  2    55.9
  3    52.2
  4    49.9
  5    47.6
  6    45.2
  7    43.7
  8    41.9
The Australian Football League has a bracket that's better than single-elimination. It has big games early on, and high-seeded teams can take a loss without being eliminated.

Australian Football League

Minor leagues

College football and college basketball dominate the pro minor leagues. For most other sports, pro minor leagues dominate colleges.


Quarterback GOAT

The contenders for quarterback GOAT are Manning, Unitas, and Rodgers. Brady has retired and may be eclipsed by Rodgers.

To quantify quarterbacks, we use Pro Bowls and playoff success.

Data table

Everyone with at least 10 Pro Bowl points is in the Hall of Fame.

Among quarterbacks that are active or recently retired, the ones guaranteed the Hall are Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Roethlisberger, and Mahomes, and Wilson. Rivers is on the bubble.

There are Hall of Famers with few Pro Bowl points but big postseason success, such as Bradshaw and Aikman.

Kemp, Lamonica, and Clark should be in the Hall of Fame. They have overwhelmingly enough points.

Roethlisberger will make the Hall because of postseason success.

Young quarterbacks have won MVPs in recent years, such as Mahones, Newton, and Jackson. Many young playes make the Pro Bowl.

Ranker.com has a quarterback ranking, which reflects the public's feelings. The public tends to favor playoff points over pro bowl points.

It has happened only once that a quarterback was MVP but not all-pro 1st team, and the quarterback is Elway.

The MVP is a quarterback 2/3 of the time.

The NFL MVP award began in 1957, and the first Pro Bowl was 1951. The NFC and AFC each designae 3 pro bowl quarterbacks. The NFL selects a quarterback as all-pro 1st team, and another as 2nd team.

Rodgers vs. Brady

Rodgers outclasses Brady head-to-head. For the years in which they both played the full season:

       Rodgers      Brady

2009   Pro Bowl     Pro Bowl
2010   -            MVP
2011   MVP          Pro Bowl
2012   All-Pro #1   Pro Bowl
2014   MVP          Pro Bowl
2015   Pro Bowl     Pro Bowl
2016   Pro Bowl     All-Pro #2
2018   Pro Bowl     -
2019   Pro Bowl     -
2020   MVP          -
2021   MVP          All-Pro #2

During this time, Rodgers has 4 MVPs and Brady has 1. Rodgers has 10 pro bowl appearances and Brady has 8.

Rodgers vs. Manning

Manning outclasses Rodgers head-to-head, but by a small margin. For the years in which they both played the full season:

       Rodgers       Manning

2008   -             MVP
2009   Pro Bowl      MVP
2010   -             Pro Bowl
2011   MVP           -
2012   Pro Bowl #2   Pro Bowl #1
2013   -             MVP
2014   MVP           Pro Bowl
2015   Pro Bowl      -

Manning has 3 MVPs and Rodgers has 2. Manning has 6 Pro Bowls and Rodgers has 5.

Timeline:

1920       NFL begins
1939-1942  All-Star games
1951       First Pro Bowl
1960       AFL begins
1966       First Super Bowl, between the NFL and the AFL
1969       AFL final season
1970       First season with the NFC-AFC format
1983-1985  United States Football League
1994       NFL salary cap starts
2024       First season of the United Football League

Official World Golf Rankings

The official world golf rankings are decided by the OWGR, a board with 7 members. The OWGR is a smoke-filled room whose methodology isn't public. The board consists of:

Board member                        Tournaments

The PGA Tour                        The Tour Championship, The Player's Championship
The PGA European Tour
International Golf Federation
The US Golf Association             U.S. Open
The PGA of America                  PGA Championship
Augusta National                    Masters
R&A Golf Club of St. Andrews        British Open

Two board seats go to the largest tours, which are the PGA Tour and the PGA European Tour. Another seat goes to the International Golf Federation, which administers amateur golf plus a set of pro golf tours. Four seats go to the owners of the Majors, which are The U.S. Open, The PGA Championship, The Masters Tournament, and the British Open.

Each tour has a season prize money total and a season ranking points total. The LIV is the second largest tour by money and gets no ranking points.

The PGA Tour bans players that play LIV. Nevertheless, many PGA Tour players joined LIV. PGA Tour members are holding conferences to discuss the matter, and there will likely be antitrust lawsuits.

The OWGR is generous to small tours. The smaller the tour, the larger the ratio of points/money tends to be.

Many 2nd tier tours are funded by a 1st tier tour, such as the PGA Korn Ferry Tour.

The European Tour has a set of premier events called the "Rolex Series", namely The Scottish Open, The BMW PGA Championship, The Abu Dhabi Golf Championship, and the Dubai Desert Classic. Each has a purse of $8 million. The European Tour final event is the DP World Tour Championship Dubai, with a purse of $10 million.

Season totals:

                 Money   Points  Points/Money
                  M$              Points/M$

PGA Tour           428   1786     4.2
LIV                225      0     0
PGA European Tour  119    886     7.4
Asian Tour          25    211     8.4
Japan Golf Tour     21    249    11.9
PGA Korn Ferry      20    364    18.2       USA
Korean Tour         14.6  145     9.9
Euro Challenge Tour  7.2  290    40.3
PGA Austalasia       4.4    2.1    .5
PGA Tour China       2.7   78    28.9
Pro Golf Tour India  2.3   50    21.7
PGA Latinoamerica    2.10  72    34.3
PGA Tour Canada      1.53  56    36.6
Japan Challenge Tour 1.53  50    32.7
Asian Development    1.5   60    40.0
Sunshine             1.42  71    50.0       Africa

U.S. Open           17.5  100     5.7     Major
Masters             15    100     6.7     Major
PGA Championship    15    100     6.7     Major
The Open Champ      14    100     7.1     Major. British Open

Player's Champ      20     80     4.0
The Tour Champ       -     39     -       Final PGA tournament
World Golf Champ    12     74     6.2

"PGA Tour" includes all tour events except the majors and The Tour Championship.


Steroid cheaters are snubbed by the Baseball Hall of Fame

The Hall snubs steroid cheaters, including Bonds, Clemens, Rodriguez, Sheffield, Ramirez, McGwire, Sosa, and Pettitte. Bonds, Clemens, and Rodriguez have stats that are overwhelmingly good enough for the Hall. Getting into the Hall requires 75% of the vote, and if you don't make it after 10 years of voting, you're removed from the ballot. The votes are:

               2022  2023  2024  Year  Steroids  Homers   ERA
                 %     %     %

Adrian Beltre    -     -    95     1               477         Inducted into the Hall 1st year
Joe Mauer        -     -    76     1               143         Inducted into the Hall 1st year
David Ortiz     78     -     -     -               541         Inducted into the Hall 1st year
Todd Helton     52    72    80     6               369         Inducted into the Hall 6th year
Scott Rolen     63    76     -     -               316         Inducted into the Hall 6th year
Billy Wagner    51    68    74     9                     2.31
Gary Sheffield  41    55    64    10       *       509
Andruw Jones    41    58    62     7               434
Carlos Beltran   -    46    57     2                           Cheated at the World Series by stealing signs
Alex Rodriguez  34    36    35     3       *       696
Manny Ramirez   29    33    32     8       *       555
Chase Utley      -     -    29     1               259
Omar Vizquel    24    20    18     7                80
Jimmy Rollins    9    13    15     3               231
Bobby Abreu      9    15    15     5               288
Andy Pettitte   11    17    14     6       *             3.85
Mark Buehrle     6    11     8     4                     3.81
Franc. Rodriguez -    11     8     2
Torii Hunter     5     7     7     4
David Wright     -     -     6     1

Barry Bonds     66     -     -   Out       *       762
Roger Clemens   65     -     -   Out       *             3.12
Curt Schilling  59     -     -   Out                     3.46
Jeff Kent       33    46     -   Out               377
Sammy Sosa      18     -     -   Out       *       609

"Year" is the number of years they've been on the ballot as of 2024.

Each elector gets 7 votes.

Bonds, Clemens, and Sosa are in their final year and they failed. They're out. The other steroid cheaters are getting few votes and are on their way out.

McGwire is a steroid cheater who's 10 years of eligibility have expired, and the highest vote percent he got was 24%.

Rafael Palmeiro was busted for steroids and only got 4.4% of Hall votes.

Carlos Beltran is a member of the Houston Astros team that cheated their way to a World Series win by stealing signs.

Jim Devlin was a pitcher with an ERA of 1.90, but was banned from baseball for colluding with gamblers.

Home run leaders

              Homers   Steroids  In Hall of Fame

Barry Bonds      762      *
Hank Aaron       755                *
Babe Ruth        714                *
Albert Pujols    703                      Retired in 2022
Alex Rodriguez   696      *
Willie Mays      660                *
Ken Griffey Jr.  630                *
Jim Thome        612                *
Sammy Sosa       609      *
Frank Robinon    586                *
Mark McGwire     583      *
Harmon Killebrew 573                *
Rafael Palmeiro  569      *
Reggie Jackson   563                *
Manny Ramirez    555      *
Mike Schmidt     548                *
...
Gary Sheffield   509      *
Miguel Cabrera   507                      Active
Nelson Cruz      459                      Active
Aaron Judge      220                      Active

Home run single-season leaders

Aaron Judge holds the single-season home run record if you exclude steroid cheats.

                Homers   Year   Steroids

Barry Bonds       73     2001     *
Mark McGwire      70     1998     *
Sammy Sosa        68     1998     *
Aaron Judge       62     2022
Roger Maris       61     1961
Babe Ruth         60     1927
Babe Ruth         59     1921
Giancarlo Stanton 59     2017
Jimmy Foxx        58     1932
Hank Greenberg    58     1938
Ryan Howard       58     2006
Mark McGwire      58     1997     *
Luis Gonzalez     57     2001
Alex Rodriguez    57     2002     *

Future Hall of Famers

Current candidates with a chance at the Hall include Scott Rolen, Todd Helton, Billy Wagner, and Andruw Jones.

Recently retired players with a strong chance at the Hall include:

2023  Carlos Beltran   (435 homers)
2024  Adrian Beltre
2024  Joe Mauer
2024  Chase Utley
2025  Ichiro Suzuki
2027  Albert Pujols    (703 homers)

Miguel Cabrera (507 home runs) is active and has a strong chance at the Hall.

Many home runs were due to steroids. All retired players with at least 493 home runs made the Hall of Fame, except for steroid cheats.

Ranker.com rankings of active players:

 1  Mike Trout        (346 homers)
 2  Mookie Betts
 3  Ronald Acuna Jr.
 4  Freddy Freeman
 5  Jacob deGrom
 6  Aaron Judge
 7  Christian Yelich
 8  Shohei Ohtani
 9  Nolan Arenado
10  Cody Bellinger

Where to put a new NFL team?

The NFL gets revenue from TV and merchandise and shares it equally between teams. League revenue is $344 million/year, 52% of which goes to players and the rest goes to owners. Teams also make their own revenue from tickets and other sources that averages $190 million per team, much less than league revenue.

Teams have widely varying team revenue. Many make more than 300 million/year and many make less than 150 million/year. Owning an NFL team is a secure investment. You could have weak ticket sales and still make money from league revenue, and the league is paying the players. The NFL is a good club to be in.
The Cowboys have the biggest team revenue. Teams with big revenue in small markets are Green Bay and Las Vegas. Teams with weak revenue in big markets are Detroit, Buffalo, Carolina, and the LA Chargers. More teams with weak revenue include Cincinnati, Arizona, and Jacksonville.

Many states don't have an NFL team but lean toward a nearby NFL team. For the Patriots' state population, we include Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Maine, New Hampshire, and Vermont. For the Panthers, we include North and South Carolina. For the Chiefs, we include Kansas and Missouri. For the Broncos, we include Colorado, Wyoming, Montana, and Idaho.

United Football League 2024

The United Football League has teams where there is no NFL team, at San Antonio, Saint Louis, Memphis, and Birmingham.

The most obvious place for a new team is San Antonio, because it's a big market, because Dallas and Houstion have big team earmings, and because Texas is the 2nd-most populous state. The states with 3 teams are California, Florida, and New York.

Oklahoma City and Salt Lake City are good places for a new team. Both have NBA teams.

San Diego and Saint Louis once had NFL teams but lost them. Portland and Sacramento are in poor economic shape. Orlando and Columbus don't deserve a team because there are nearby NFL teams and the nearby teams have weak revenue. Birmingham hosted all USFL games but the city lost money and the league had weak revenue. The XFL teams in markets without an NFL team are San Antonio, Saint Louis, and Portland.

In Canada, the big markets are Toronto, Montreal, and Vancouver.

The places that deserve a new team are San Antonio, Oklahoma City, Salt Lake City, Toronto, Montreal, Europe, and Asia. A weak team could move to a better market. A team could also play in multiple cities, bringing games to small markets.

The Bills could change its name to the Great Lakes Bills and play most of its games in Toronto, while keeping a subset of games at Buffalo.

The name "Carolina" is diplomatic because it doesn't specify a city, and because it encompases both North and South Carolina. The stadium is on the border of the 2 states.

The name "Tennessee" is diplomatic. The team is at the center of the state and it's near the north border with Kentucky. The team could have been called the Appalachia Titans, and could potentially play games in Tennessee, Kentucky, Alabama, Arkansas, and West Virginia.

The big college stadiums that are far from an NFL team are Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Nebraska, Iowa, Iowa State, West Virginia, Arkansas, Kentucky, and Oregon. There are no big stadiums in Montana or its surrounding states. The big stadiums in Canada are in Montreal, Edmonton, and Vancouver. Toronto's stadium is small.

NFL teams are worth on average $4.5 billion and the Cowboys are worth $7.6 billion. Entering a new team in the NFL would likely cost at least $6 billion.

NFL Europe ran from 1995-2007. In the final season there were 5 teams were in Germany and 1 in Amsterdam. The German teams were Frankfurt, Rhein, Berlin, Cologne, and Hamburg. There were once teams in London, Scotland, and Barcelona, but they were replaced by German teams.

Many nations can support an NFL team, such as Canada, Mexico, England, France, Germany, Spain, Italy, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and India. These nations have lots of large stadiums. The NFL has played 33 games in London, 5 in Mexico City, and 1 in Germany.

America has a pro rugby league 12 teams and an ESPN contract, and this is an opportunity for markets without an NFL team. At present, all pro rugby teams are in big markets. It costs 4 million dollars to enter a team into Major League Rugby. Most American colleges have a rugby team.

Major League Rugby

Green Bay is a small town and the Packers have big team revenue.

Green Bay, Wisconsin, population 104057
Lambeau Field, capacity 81435, always sold out

NFL, NBA, and MLB teams tend to be in the same places. The markets with an NBA team and no NFL team are Oklahoma, Sacramento, Portland, Salt Lake City, and Toronto. The markets with an NFL team and no NBA team are Las Vegas, Seattle, Kansas City, Tampa Bay, and Buffalo. We consider Jacksonville and Orlando to be the same market, and we consider Green Bay and Milwaukee to be the same market.

The large markets that don't have an NFL, NBA, MLB, or NHL team are Virginia and Montreal.

National Football League
National Basketball Association

Baseball, Major League
Baseball, AAA League

NHL and MLS teams are often in different places from NFL teams.

National Hockey League
Major League Soccer

Baseball AAA teams exist in places without major league teams.

The biggest stadiums are:

Teams have an average attendance of 570,000 people/year, the average ticket price is $107, and the average team ticket revenue is $61 million.

In 2022, the Packers got $344 million of league revenue and $235 million of team revenue, totaling $579 million. Expenses were $501 million and profit was $78 million. League TV revenue is $312 million and local TV and radio revenue is $92 million. The Packers' team revenue is:

                     %   Million $

Local TV & radio    39     92
Tickets             20     47
Merchandise         16     38
Property            15     35
Concessions          6     14
Luxury boxes         5     12

The Packers' team expenses are:

                     %

Players             61
Administration      14
Team expenses       12
Marketing           10
Game expenses        3

Revenue:

                         Million $

NFL                        17000
American college football   4000
Canadian Football League     180
USFL                          50
Fan Controlled Football       20
XFL                           14
Arena Football League         13

The playoffs are 10% of TV viewership. For 2022,

            Viewers/Game   Total viewers
              millions       millions

Super Bowl        112         112
Conference round   50         100
Divisional round   36         144
Wildcard round     29         174
Regular season     16.7      4540

A team needs a city and a stadium. For states without an NFL team, the candidates are:

            City      Metro pop  State pop  Stadium   Stadium site
                         Mil        Mil     capacity

Oklahoma    Oklahoma C  2.8       3.9       86112     Oklahoma U
Utah        Provo       2.7       3.4       63470     Brigham Young U
Iowa        Iowa City    .28      3.2       70586     Iowa U
Iowa        Ames         .89      3.2       61500     Iowa State U
Nebraska    Lincoln      .26      2.0       86047     Nebraska U
W Virginia  Morgantown   .11      1.8       60000     West Virginia U

The NFL could open up to interleague play by eliminating the salary cap.


New team other than the NFL

Buying into a league costs money.

League            Revenue   Buy-in  Average  Attendance  New team    Year  Teams  Teams outside   Candidates
                  B$/year     M$    pay (M$)  average                                  USA

Football    NFL        19     ~4000  2.7       67000     ?              Future  32        0     No near-term candidates
Baseball    MLB        11     ~2000  4.2       27000     ?              Future  30        1     Vegas
Basketball  NBA        10.3   ~2000  7.7       18000     ?              Future  30        1     Vegas, Seattle, Vancouver
Hockey      NHL         5.3     650  3.2       18000     Seattle Kraken 2018    32        7     Houston, Kansas City, Quebec C, Toronto
Soccer      MLS         1.6     325   .051     21000     San Diego      2025    30        3     Vegas
Rugby       MLR         ~.4       4   .04       2200     Miami Sharks   2024    13        1     No near-term candidates

Football    NCAA        4.0
Football    UFL                       .04                                        8        0
Football    USFL         .050         .053                                       8        0
Football    FCF          .020                                                    8        0
Football    XFL          .014         .05                                        8        0
Football    Arena        .013                                                   16        0

Basketball  WNBA         .54     50   .12       5700     ?              Future  12        0     No near-term candidates
Soccer      NWSL         ?       50   .038      7900     Utah Royals    2024    14        0     Cinn, Austin, Columbus, Nashville
Hockey      PWHL         ?        ?   .015               Montreal Force 2022     7        2

Soccer      England 1   6.6     400            38000                            20       20     Promotion/relegation system
Baseball    Japan 1     1.18                   31000                            12       12
Cricket     India 1     1.18                   30000                            12       12
Rugby       Australia 1  .96                   33000                            18       18
Rugby       England 1    .25                   14500                            11       11
Football    Canada 1     .18                   23000                             9        9

Las Vegas and Seattle just built NHL stadiums, which can also be basketball stadiums. A hockey sideline is 5.5 meters farther out than a basketball sideline. They just established NHL teams and they're looking to establish NBA teams

NFL teams range in value from 3 to 8 billion dollars. English Premiere League soccer teams are worth between .5 and 5 billion dollars.

Moves and exits:

                      Old team          New team         Year

Football   NFL        Oakland Raiders   Las Vegas        2020
                      SD Chargers       LA Chargers      2017
                      St. Louis Rams    LA               2016
                      Houston Texans    Tennessee Titans 1997
                      LA Raiders        Oakland          1995
                      LA Rams           St Louis         1995
                      St Louis Cardinal Arizona          1988
                      Baltimore Colts   Indianapolis     1984
                      Oakland Raiders   LA               1982
Basketball  NBA       New Jersey        Brooklyn         2012
                      Seattle           Oklahoma City    2008
                      Charlotte         New Orleans      2002
                      Vancouver         Memphis          2001
Soccer      Women's   Utah              Kansas City      2020
                      Boston Breakers   Exit             2017
                      Kansas City       Utah             2016
                      W New York Flash  North Carolina   2016
Rugby       MLR       Austin            Exit             2023
                      Los Angeles       Exit             2023
                      Colorado          Exit             2020
Basketball  Women's   San Antonio       Las Vegas        2018
                      Tulsa             Dallas           2016
                      Detroit           Tulsa            2010
                      Sacramento        Exit             2009
                      Houston           Exit             2008
                      Charlotte         Exit             2006
                      Utah              San Antonio      2003
                      Orlando           Connecticut      2003
                      Cleveland         Exit             2003
                      Miami             Exit             2002
                      Portland          Exit             2002

Regions with lots of teams:

              Football  Basketball  Baseball  Hockey  Soccer  Rugby  Soccer  Basketball
                                                                     Women's  Women's

New York City      2        2          2        3       1       1     1        1
Los Angeles        2        2          2        2       2       1     1        1
San Francisco      1        1          2        1       1             1
Chicago            1        1          2        1       1             1        1
Philadelphia       1        1          1        1       1
DC                 1        1          1        1       1       1     1        1
Boston             1        1          1        1       1       1              1
Dallas             1        1          1        1       1       1              1
Minneapolis        1        1          1        1       1       1              1
Miami              1        1          1        1       1       1
Denver             1        1          1        1       1
Phoenix            1        1          1        1                              1
Milwaukee          1        1          1                                           Packers included
Houston            1        1          1        *       1       1     1
Atlanta            1        1          1                1       1              1
Detroit            1        1          1        1
North Carolina     1        1                   1                              1
Tennessee          1        1                   1       1
Seattle            1        *          1        1       1       1     1        1
Tampa Bay          1                   1        1
Indianapolis       1        1                                                  1
New Orleans        1        1                                   1
Kansas City        1        1                   *       1             1
Baltimore          1                   1
Las Vegas          1        *          1        1       *                      1   Will likely add teams
Saint Louis                 1                   1       *
Toronto                     1          1        1       1       1
Salt Lake City              1                           1       1     1
Oklahoma City               1
San Antonio                 1                           *             1
Portland                    1                           1             1
San Diego                              1                        1     1
Montreal                                        1

              Football  Basketball  Baseball  Hockey  Soccer  Rugby  Soccer  Basketball
                                                                     Women's  Women's

A "*" indicates that an expansion team is under consideration.


New stadiums

The table shows the contributons for stadium constructon.

                                 Team  Public  Private  Total  Year
                                  M$     M$      M$      M$

Buffalo Bills      Buffalo        350    850    200    1400  Future   NFL
Tennessee Titans   Nashville      840    500    760    2100  Future   NFL
Las Vegas Raiders  Las Vegas     1100    750      0    1850    2020   NFL + college football + Las Vegas Bowl
Los Angeles Rams   Los Angeles                         5500    2020   NFL + LA Bowl
Las Vegas Knights  Las Vegas       56      0    319     375    2017   NHL
Atlanta Falcons    Atlanta                             1500    2014   NFL + Peach Bowl + SEC conf champ game
Minnesota Vikings  Minneapolis                         1100    2013   NFL
San Francisco 49   San Francisco                       1300    2012   NFL + San Francisco Bowl
New York Giants    E. Rutherford                       1700    2010   NFL + XFL
Dallas Cowboys     Dallas                              1480    2009   NFL + Cotton Bowl

President golf rankings

Kennedy
Ford
Clinton
Bush 43
Obama
Trump

        Golf rank       Golf rank        Golf       Golf       Athlete rank
       Golf Digest   Bleacher Report   handicap  rounds/year   Golf Digest

Trump        1             1             2.8         91              Winner of 19 club championships. Owns 17 golf courses
Kennedy      2             3             8                       4   Harvard golf team
Eisenhower   3             2            13          100          5   Installed a green on the White House lawn
Ford         4             7                                     1   Michigan football team, in the year that Michigan won the national championship
Roosevelt T  5                                                   2
Bush 41      6                          10                       3
Bush 43      7             6            11            3          8   Hits 18 holes 2 hours. Doesn't take practice swings
Clinton      8             4
Obama        9             5            13           42          7
Reagan      10                                                   6
Harding     11
Taft        12
Wilson      13
Nixon       14                                                       Shot a 79
Johnson     15
Coolidge    16                                                       Left behind his clubs upon departing the White House
Wilson                                  25          250         10   Played in the winter and painted his balls black
Biden                                   10
Pence                                   15
Lincoln                                                          9

Jack Nicklaus: "Trump loves the game of golf more than he loves money"


President athlete rankings

Modern organized sports give us quantitative information about athletic prowess. Ranking presidents from before the age of organized sports is difficult and we fall back on anecdotes.

Tier 1   Ford
Tier 2   Washington  Grant   Eisenhower  Trump
Tier 3   Lincoln     Teddy   Kennedy     Carter    Reagan  Bush 41  Bush 43  RFK Jr
Tier 4   Jackson     Taylor  Harrison    McKinley  Taft    Wilson   Truman   Nixon   Biden
Tier 5   Everyone else
Tier 6   Cleveland   FDR

Washington   Mighty horseman. Big and strong. Wrestler.
             Could crush a walnut with his thumb and index finger.
             Army General of the Armies
             Fought many battles and had many horses shot out from under him.
             His coat and hat are full of bullet holes.
             Has more horse miles than most modern Americans have air miles.
Jefferson    Virginia Militia Colonel
Madison      Virginia Militia Colonel
Monroe       Virginia Militia Colonel
Jackson      Army Major General
Taylor       Army Major General
Tyler        Army Colonel
Polk         Tennessee Captain
Harrison     Army Major General
Fillmore     New York Militia Major
Pierce       Army Brigadier General
Buchanan     Army Private
Lincoln      County wrestling champion. Defeated many renowned wrestlers.
             Master of the axe. Army Captain
Johnson A    Brigadier General
Grant        Best horse rider and horse trainer in America, in an era where horsemanship mattered.
             Army General of the Armies
Hayes        Army Major General
Garfield     Army Major General
Arthur       New York Militia Brigadier General
Harrison     Army Brigadier General
Cleveland    Renowned as a bad athlete
McKinley     Army Captain
Roosevelt, T Played all sports, including boxing and wrestling. Army Colonel
             Climbed the Matterhorn
Taft         Yale heavyweight intramural wrestling champion
Wilson       Davidson U baseball starter. Princeton rugby coach. Played more golf rounds
             than any president.
FDR          Undistinguished as a student or athlete. Harvard cheerleader
Truman       Army Colonel
Eisenhower   U.S. Military Academy starting halfback. Gymnast, boxer, fencer, horseman.
             Football coach for Peacock Military Academy and St. Mary's University.
             Army General of the Army. Golf handicap 13. Installed a golf green at the White House
Kennedy      Harvard golf starter and swimming starter. Football JV. Golf handicap 8.
             Harvard sailing starter. Won the Eastern Collegiate Championship. Navy Lieutenant
Johnson L    Navy Commander
Nixon        Whittier football and basketball team. Navy Commander. Bowler
Kennedy, R   No record of sports
Ford         Michigan U football starting center and linebacker.
             Team MVP. College all-star. The Michigan team won the national championship.
             Yale football and boxing coach. Navy Lieutenant Commander
Carter       Naval academy sprint football starter, baseball starter, and cross country starter.
             High school basketball starter. Navy Lieutenant
Reagan       Eureka College football starter and swim starter. Great physique.
             Sports broadcaster. Portrayed The Gipper in "Knute Rockne".
             Honored with a gold medal at the International Swimming Hall of Fame.
             Army Captain
Bush 41      High school football captain and baseball captain. Yale baseball captain.
             Played in the college baseball world series. Golf handicap 10. Navy Lieutenant
Bush 43      Yale rugby starter. High school baseball starter. Golf handicap 10.
             Ran a marathon in 3:44:52. Air National Guard First Lieutenant
             Owned the Texas Rangers
Obama        Little athletic background. Pickup basketball player but was not on any varsity team.
Trump        Golf handicap 3. High school football starter, soccer starter, and baseball starter.
             Member of the WWE Hall of Fame. Owned the New Jersey Generals football team.
             Owns 19 golf courses. Gets cheers when attending sports events.
             People make glorious memes depicting Trump as a badass.
Biden        High school football starter and baseball starter. Golf handicap 10
RFK Jr       Mighty physique, and he still has it as an elder. Falconer

The mainstream media likes to tout Obama as a great athlete, and that he played basketball at Occidental college. There is no record of him being associated with the Occidental basketball team. It's a myth. Obama's jump shot is poor. He can't bend his knees and he can't maneuver. He doesn't jump, and his release point is sadly low, at the level of his head. When Obama threw out the first pitch at a baseball game, it was a weak pitch and it was way out of the strike zone.

Presidents that installed sports at the White House:

Teddy       Tennis
Truman      Bowling, horseshoes
Eisenhower  Golf green
Ford        Pool
Obama       Basketball

President athlete rankings for their last day of office

A president's fitness on the last day of office matters. Jay's ranks:

         Age on     Years alive
        last day  after presidency

Ford        63   29   Michigan football center & linebacker. Team MVP. College all-star
Grant       54    8   Best Horseman in America
Washington  65    2   Mighty horseman. Big and strong. Wrestler
Teddy       50    9   Boxed and wrestled while prez
Lincoln     56    0   Master wrestler and lumberjack
Kennedy     46    0   Harvard starter golf & swimming. Football JV. Golf handi 8
Carter      56  >42   Naval acad starter football, baseball, x country
RFK Sr      47    ?
Eisenhower  70    8   Army acad starting halfback. All sports
RFK Jr      74    ?   Fit at old age
Bush 43     62  >14   Yale rugby starter. HS baseball starter. Golf handicap 10
Trump       82    ?   Golf handicap of 3. Still a badass golfer
Jackson     69    8
Bush 41     68   25   Yale baseball captain. HS football captain
Garfield    49    0
Taft        55   17
Clinton     54  >22
Polk        53    0
Nixon       61   19   Enthusiastically participates at football practice
Obama       55   >6   No record of being on a sports team
Reagan      77   15   Eureka College starter football & swim
Adams, JQ   61   18
Adams, J    65   25
Cleveland   59    4   Left his golf clubs behind upon leaving White House
Wilson      64    2   Stroke
Hillary     73   >3   Infirm
Biden       86    -   Demented and infirm
FDR         63    0   Died of old age while in office

We consider hypothetical presidents such as RFK Sr, RFK Jr, and Hillary Clinton.

FDR died of old age while in office. That's why he's ranked last. For Trump, age 82 is for if he wins a second term.


Military

General of the Army   Washington  Grant       Eisenhower
Major General         Jackson     Harrison W  Taylor      Hayes       Garfield
Brigadier General     Arthur      Pierce      Johnson A   Harrison B
Colonel               Jefferson   Madison     Monroe      Polk        Teddy     Truman
Commander             Johnson L   Nixon
Major                 Fillmore
Lieutenant Commander  Ford
Captain               Tyler       Lincoln     McKinley    Reagan
Lieutenant            Kennedy     Carter      Bush 41
First Lieutenant      Bush 43
Private               Buchanan

DC golf

David Perdue
Trey Gowdy
Donald Trump
Roger Williams
Bob Corker
Mick Mulvaney
Jim Renacci

Golf Digest ranked the best 150 golfers in DC.

              Handicap  Rank

Tony Russo       -3.1     1
Rob Ellsworth    -1.8     2
David Perdue      -.6     3     Senate      R
Trey Gowdy        1.0     7     House       R
Donald Trump      2.8    12     President   R
Roger Williams    4.9    23     House       R
Bob Corker        5.2    26     Senate      R
Mick Mulvaney     8.0    42     House       R
Jim Renacci       9.6    63     House       R
Joe Biden        10      68     VP          D
Rick Allen       10      68     House       R
Dean Heller      10      68     Senate      R
Tom Rooney       10      68     House       R
Albio Sires      10.2    77     House       D
Ron Johnson      10.6    88     Senate      R
Richard Burr     11.3    86     Senate      R
Pete Aguilar     12      92     House       D
Xavier Becerra   12      92     House       D
Chris Collins    12      92     House       R
Jeff Duncan      12      92     House       R
John Hoeven      12      92     Senate      R
Duncan Hunter    12      92     House       R
Ron Kind         12      92     House       D
Brad Ashford     12.3   102     House       D
Pat Meehan       12.3   102     House       R
Dan Kildee       12.8   107     House       D
Phil Roe         12.8   107     House       R
Ander Crenshaw   12.9   111     House       R
Barack Obama     13     113     President   D
Lindsey Graham   13     113     Senate      R
Mike Pence       15     127     VP          R

Trump National, Los Angeles


Sports variations

Pickleballl

The ball is too loud. Design a quieter ball.

Give tennis courts lines for pickleball, and make nets adjustible to handle both tennis and pickleball.


Soccer

Delete the offsides rule. It requires extra policing.

Add territory behind the goal, like hockey.

Decrease the number of players or increase the number of balls. u

Increase goal width. Don't increase height. Goal height is already appropriate for a goalie of averge height.


Tennis scoring

Tennis scoring has the virtue that you can make a comeback even if way behind. On the other hand, you don't know how many sets a match will have. Other sports could adopt a scoring system analogous to tennis, which eliminates trash time. For example, a football game could be played with 5 periods, with 1 point for winning a period and half a point for tying. Play overtime if necessary.

If a game ends after less than 5 periods, play the JV for the last periods, or shift TV coverage to a new game.


Hockey

Make the goal substantially wider and taller.

Make the goalie wear a standard jersey. Not oversized. Make the pads minimum width. Use a standard stick.

Make the puck rounded at the edges so that it's easier to lift.

Have a period that's 5 on 5.


Rugby

Eliminate the kick. It's too powerful.

Eliminate the lineout. If the ball goes out of bounds, treat it like a soccer throw-in, and require that the pass be backward.

Eliminate the scrum.

Have a version of the game with 11 players.

If possible, have more than 1 referee.

Delete rucks. If you get the ball to the ground, you get a clean restart.

You get a maximum of 8 downs before the ball turns over.

Have an overhead drone to call forward passes and knocks.

The goalpost legs are at the 0 yard line. Move them back and out of the end zone, like football goalposts.


Ping pong

Ping pong is perfect. It fits indoors. You can be skilled even if not athletic.


Golf

Widen fairways to reward heavy hitters.


Darts

A dart board should be like archery, with concetric scoring.

Make the dart board an oval, more tall than wide, to because vertical accuracy is less than horizontal accuracy.

An archery target has rings that are all the same width. Rings should widen as they go out. For example:

  N    Points   Ring outer
                  radius

  1      8         1
  2      7         1.5
  3      6         2
  4      5         3
  5      4         4
  6      3         6
  7      2         8
  8      1        12

You could further make ring radii exponential, where "1.5" is replaced by "sqrt(2)". "3" is replaced by "2*sqrt(2)", etc.

Ring radius = 2(N-1)/2
Ring area   = π 2N-2   except for the ring "N=1", which has an area of pi

It may be desirable to make the inner ring smaller, to preserve the progression of ring areas. Perhaps make the inner ring radius "3/4".

If the projectile radius is a substantial fraction of ring width, it maybe desirable to move ring radii inward.


Dodgeball

Eliminate the catch rule. Be able to wantonly hurl balls at people without worry.

Use foam balls, like Nerf balls.

Use points. If you score a hit, it's a point. Don't remove the hit player. Keep the game sporting.


Foosball

Foosball is loud. Confine it to loud places or design a quieter ball.


Football

Delete the kickoff. It's dangerous.


Basketball

Wrestling has weight classes. Basketball should have height classes. For example, specify 5 height classes, and there must be a player on the court that satifies each class. Or, specify an overall height, and the combined height of players on the court must be less than the overall height.

Delete the 3 point rule.

Delete the paint rule.

Delete free throws. They're boring. If there's a foul, give 2 points.


New Sport

The sports industry has inertia that protects existing sports and inhibits new sports. Most sports have awkward rules and better sports are possible. The most glaring need is for a better tackle sport, because the rules for football and rugby are awkward.

Rules should be simple and elegant. Good examples include soccer, hockey, and tennis, and bad examples include football, rugby, baseball, and basketball.

Football has the negative that it requires many coaches.

A sport should accomodate a diversity of body types. Rugby has roles for everyone, regardless of size. Basketball overemphasizes height.

A sport should minimize equipment. Football and hockey require excessive equipment, whereas soccer requires only a ball.

For football, the XFL courageously experiments with the rules.

Rugby and soccer have too many players. Either the number of players can be reduced or the number of balls can be increased.


Scoring

The challenge is to convert a set of event scores into a total score. For example, Formula-1 has 22 races per season, and points from each race are summed to decide the season winner.

In the plot, points are normalized so that the rank #1 team gets 1 point. The un-normalized point systems are:

Rank  World  F-1  Indy  NASCAR  Tennis  Golf  Bowling  Tour de  Science
     Cup ski                     ATP    PGA     PBA    France   Olympiad

  1    100   25    50     10    2000     600   7500      50       60
  2     80   18    40      9    1200     330   4500      30       59
  3     60   15    35      8     720     210   3450      20       58
  4     50   12    32      7     720     150   2850      18       57
  5     45   10    30      6     360     120   2550      16       56
  6     40    8    28      5     360     110             14       55
  7     36    6    26      4     360     100             12       54
  8     32    4    24      3     360      94             10       53
  9     29    2    22      2     180      88              8       52
 10     26    1    20      1     180      82              7       51
 11     24    1    19            180      77              6       50
 12     22         18            180      72              5       49
 13     20         17            180      68              4       48
 14     18         16            180      64              3       47
 15     16         15            180      61              2       46
 16     15         14            180      59                      45
 32      2          5             90      28                      29
 64                               45       4.76
128                               10

For the Tour de France, points are awarded for each stage, and at the end of the tour, the points winner is honored as the sprint champion.

The NASCAR and Science Olympiad functions are goofy because they give too little emphasis to top finishers. The tennis and golf functions give too much emphasis to top finishers.

The Science Olympiad function is for 2001 and after. Before 2001, the Science Olympiad used NASCAR scoring.

Ideally, the score function should have a linear shape in a plot where the X axis is logarithmic. Sports with a sensible scoring function include Formula-1, Indy racing, and World Cup skiing.

Suppose there are 64 players. A point function that gives a linear shape in the plot is:

Rank  Points

  1     6
  2     5
  4     4
  8     3
 16     2
 32     1
 64     0

In a single-elimination tournament with 64 players, points corresponds to the number of games won.

This can be expressed as

Points = -log2(Rank/64)


Prize money

Tennis and golf give big money to players outside the top 128.

Numbers are season winnings for 2021 season, in k$.

Rank   Golf  Tennis  Bowling  Golf  Golf   Tennis  Tennis   Tennis  Tennis  Ski   Tour  Bowl  Pong Pickle  Pool
       PGA    ATP      PBA     US   PGA      US    Wimble-  French  Aussie         de    US   World  US     US
       total total    total   Open  Champ   Open   don       Open    Open  total France Open  Champ Open   Open

   1   11215   9069    497   4300   3300   3600   2700     2400    3150   810    624  100     45   5.5    50
   2    7167   7466    370   2322   1998   1800   1400     1200    1725   366    251   50     35   2.75   25
   3                         1430   1258                                  317    169   25          1.25   13
   4    5821   3504    188   1030    888   1000    715      650     990   288     84   15     26    .75   13
   5                          844    740                                  220     80   10           .25    6.75
   6                          748    661                                          75    8           .25    6.75
   7                                 618                                          66    6.6         .25    6.75
   8    4878   2231           600    578    530    375      415     600           57    6     18    .25    6.75
   9                                                                              35    5.4
  10                                 502                                          33    5.15
  12                                 433                                                4.65
  16    3909   1618           299    317    325    226      250     375                 3.65  12           4.5
  24                                 170                                                2.4
  32    2596   1031           111     97    215    143      158     255                 1.5                3
  48                                  47
  64    1491    669            41     27    140     93      110     180                                    1.75
  74                           39
  78                                  22
  96     967    492
 128     738                           4    100     60       73     120            1                       1
 160     468
 192     211
 208     157
 224      75
 240      17
 256       7                                 53     40       41      65
 512                                         38     25       28      44
1024                                         25     15       20      31

Total 371260 170000         18500                                 86500               297
Average 1485

A hypothetical golfer that makes par on every hole would be 183rd in the money rankings.


International Rugby

Conferences

International rugby is well structured. Some of its strengths are:

Within conferences, teams are well balanced in terms of strength.

Conferences make sense geographically.

Each conference completes a single or double round robin each year. Conference results carry weight because the World Cup occurs only once every 4 years.

There are abundant interconference matches, both between top-tier teams and between top-tier and lesser teams.

Conferences are flexible and there exists upward mobility. For example Argentina established itself by making the World Cup semifinal in 2007 and was invited to join the Tri Nations in 2011, since known as The Rugby Championship.

Teams can take temporary leave of absence from conferences.

Teams can play in multiple ocnferences. For example the USA, Canada, and Japan often compete in the Pacific Nations Cup.

Teams can schedule games with whoever they want, and there is no limit to the number of times two two teams can play per year.

There are several national #2 teams, such as New Zealand #2 and Argentia #2.

There are subregional conferences such as "Europe 6 Nations B" and "Asian Division 1".

There exist teams independent of nations, such as The Barbarians and The British & Irish Lions.

Each team plays around 12 games per year and these games are chosen wisely. Matches are almost always compelling because both conference and interconference results carry weight.

Matchups between top teams occur frequently enough that a world champion can be meaningfully defined using results from the previous 2 years.


College Wrestling
            Championships

Oklahoma State  34
Iowa            24
Penn State       9
Iowa State       8
Oklahoma         7
Minnesota        3
Ohio State       1
Arizona State    1
Michigan State   1
Northern Iowa    1
Cornell College  1
Indiana          1


Big Twelve      49
Big Ten         39
Other            3
Few schools outside of the Midwest have won championships.

NCAA hockey

Big Ten
Hockey East

ECAC Hockey

Men's hockey:

            Championships   Frozen Four

Michigan             9       24
North Dakota         7       21
Denver               7       14
Wisconsin            6       12
Boston College       5       24
Boston University    5       22
Minnesota            5       21
Lake Superior State  3        4
Michigan State       3       11
Michigan Tech        3       10
Cornell              2        8
Maine                2       11
Colorado College     2       10
RPI                  2        5
Minnesota-Duluth     1        4
Harvard              1       12
Providence           1        4
Bowling Green        1
Northern Michigan    1
Union                1
Yale                 1
St Lawrence                   9
Clarkson                      7
New Hampshire                 7
Dartmouth                     4
Women's hockey:
               Championships   Final

Minnesota-Duluth     5          6
Minnesota            5          7
Wisconsin            4          6
Clarkson             1          1
Harvard                         4

NCAA rugby

Varsity Club Championship teams:

Arizona State     Air Force       Arkansas State    BYU       California
Cent. Washington  Clemson         Dartmouth         Navy      Notre Dame
Oklahoma          Texas           UCLA              UTAH
Division 1-A Rugby:
East:        Army,  Delaware,  Kutztown,  Penn State,  Wheeling Jesuit
             St. Bonaventure,  Iona,  University at Buffalo
Mid-South:   Lindenwood,  Life University,  Davenport University
California:  Cal Poly,  Saint Mary's,  UC Davis,  San Diego State,
             UC Santa Barbara,  Santa Clara,  Sacramento State,  Stanford
West:        Colorado,  Colorado State,  Wyoming  Northern Colerado,  New Mexico


            Championships

California       25
BYU               4
Air Force         3
Harvard           1
San Diego State   1
The Varsity Club conference was formed in 2013.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varsity_Cup_Championship
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Division_1-A_Rugby


UK Premier League oligarch teams

Numbers are for 2001-2017. All teams with at least one placement in the top 3 are included.

                  Champ  2nd  3rd

Manchester U        7     3    3
Chelsea             5     4    3
Arsenal             2     4    4
Manchester City     2     2    2
Liverpool                 3    3
Tottenham                 1    1
Leicester City      1
Newcastle U                    1

FCS realignment

State strength

FCS conferences can realign to be geographically compact and to have fewer teams. For example,

E Wash            Washington
Portland St       Oregon
Idaho             Idaho
Idaho St          Idaho
Montana St        Montana
Montana           Montana
Weber St          Utah
S Utah            Utah
Utah T            Utah
N Colorado        Colorado

North Dakota      North Dakota
North Dakota St   North Dakota
South Dakota      South Dakota
South Dakota St   South Dakota
Saint Thomas      Minnesota
Drake             Iowa
Butler            Iowa
N Iowa            Iowa

Illinois St       Illinois
W Illinois        Illinois
E Illinois        Illinois
S Illinois        Illinois
Indiana St        Indiana
Valpariso         Indiana
Youngstown St     Ohio
Dayton            Ohio
SE Missouri St    Missouri
Lindenwood        Missouri
Missouri St       Missouri

Murray St         Kentucky
Morehead St       Kentucky
E Kentucky        Kentucky
Austin peay       Tennessee
Tennessee Martin  Tennessee
Tennessee Tech    Tennessee
Tennessee St      Tennessee
Chattanooga       Tennessee
E Tennessee St    Tennessee

UC Davis          California
Sacramento St     California
Cal Poly          California
San Diego         California
N Arizona         Arizona

Abilene Christian Texas
Tarleton St       Texas
Incarnate Word    Texas
Stephen Austin    Texas
Lamar             Texas
Houston Christian Texas
E Texas AM        Texas
Prairie View AM   Texas
Texas S           Texas

Arkansas Pine Blu Arkansas
C Arkansas        Arkansas
SE Louisiana      Louisiana
Nichols           Louisiana
McNeese           Louisiana
Northwestern St   Louisiana
Southern          Louisiana
Grambling St      Louisiana

Jackson St        Mississippi
Mississippi Va St Mississippi
Alcorn St         Mississippi
N Alabama         Alabama
Alabama St        Alabama
Alabama AM        Alabama
Samford           Alabama
Mercer            Georgia
W Georgia         Georgia

Maine             Maine
New Hampshire     New Hampshire
Stonehill         Massachusetts
Holy Cross        Massachusetts
Rhode Island      Rhode Island
Bryant            Rhode Island
C Connecticut     Connecticut

Stony Brook       New York
Albany            New York
Marist            New York
Colgate           New York
Fordham           New York
Wagner            New York       Staten
LIU               New York
Monmouth          New Jersey

Georgetown        Pennsylvania
Lehigh            Pennsylvania
Lafayette         Pennsylvania
Villanova         Pennsylvania
Duquesne          Pennsylvania
Robert Morris     Pennsylvania
Saint Francis     Pennsylvania
Mercyhurst        Pennsylvania

Delaware St       Delaware
Delaware          Delaware
Morgan St         Maryland
Towson            Maryland
Bucknell          DC
Howard            DC
Richmond          Virginia
William Mary      Virginia
Hampton           Virginia
VMI               Virginia
Norfolk St        Virginia

Gardner Webb      North Carolina
Davidson          North Carolina
North Carolina C  North Carolina
W Carolina        North Carolina
Elon              North Carolina
Campbell          North Carolina
North Carolina AT North Carolina

South Carolina St South Carolina
Charleston S      South Carolina
Presbyterian      South Carolina
Citadel           South Carolina
Wofford           South Carolina
Furman            South Carolina
Stetson           Florida
Florida AM        Florida
Bethune Cookman   Florida

The California conference could add California schools from outside Division 1, and schools exist with lots of students, such as

         Thousands of students

UC San Diego     43
Fullerton St     40
Northridge St    39
UC Irvine        37
Long Beach St    37
San Francisco St 30
Los Angeles St   28
UC Santa Barbara 26
UC Riverside     26
Pomona St        26

The FCS California schools could secede from their conferences and form a California conference, and invite teams from outside Division 1.


Stadium design

A stadium can be suspended, and the luxury boxes can be close to the field.

The largest stadiums have 1 deck. The Michigan stadium is mostly below ground level. One could make a large cheap 1-deck stadium by digging a hole and pouring concrete.

                        1st deck  2nd deck  3rd deck  4th deck  Total  Seats  Seats/Row
                          rows      rows      rows      rows    rows

Dallas Cowboys  AT&T          22      15        16        30      83    80000     964
Texas A&M U     Kyle          33      38        37               108   102733     951
NY Giants       MetLife       35      14        26                75    82500    1115
Houston Texans  NRG           36      22        25                83    72220     870
La Rams         So Fi         38      14        22                74    70000     946
Ohio St. U      Ohio Stadium  80      50                         130   102780     791
LSU             Tiger         65      29                          94   102321    1089
Tennessee U     Neyland       64      23                          87   101915    1171
Texas U         Royal         78      25                         103   100119     972
Michigan U      Big House     98                                  98   107601    1121
Penn St. U      Beaver        80                                  80   106572    1332
UCLA            Rose Bowl     88                                  88    92542    1052
Green Bay Pack  Lambeau       78                                  78    81441    1044

Indian Cricket  Narendra Modi                                          132000           Largest stadium dedicated to cricket
Michigan soccer Big House                                              107601
FC Barcelona    Camp Nou                                                99354           Largest stadium dedicated to soccer
LA Dodgers      Dodger Stadium                                          56000           Largest baseball stadium in the world
U.S. Open tennis  Arthur Ashe                                           23771           Largest tennis stadium in the world
Montreal Canadiens  Bell Center                                         21105           Largest stadium dedicated to hockey
Philippine BBall  Quezon                                                20000           Largest stadium dedicated to basketball
Japan sumo      Ryogoku Kokugikan                                       20000           Largest stadium dedicated to sumo

The highest a football pass can go is 24 meters. You want as many seats as possible to see the top of the pass, and these are "highball seats". You also want seats that go further back and can see the opposite sideline. The "lowball seats".

You want abundant lounge space so you can be at the stadium all day and be comfortable. The stadium should have a commercial district.

You can have tickets that give access to the stadium but don't have a stadium seat. You can watch the game in a lounge on a jumbotron and be a part of the stadium crowd. Many lounge seats have partial visibiity of the field.

Suspending a stadium deck is easy. The Golden Gate Bridge span is 1280 meters and a stadium span is 200 meters.

A hockey and basketball stadium can be combined. The hockey sideline is 5.5 meters out from the basketball sideline. In basketball mode, seats can be added. The basketball court is lower than the hockey ice.

It's not easy to combine a football stadium with a soccer or rugby stadium. Compared to a football sideline, a soccer sideline is 9.5 meters further out and a rugby sideline is 10.5 meters further out. Field width is more important for rugby than for soccer, so a football stadium can work for soccer by using a narrow field, but it can't support rugby.